The NPD sales data for March just hit and it's bad news all around for fans of M-rated games on Nintendo hardware, but especially bad news for Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars. Despite being the best-reviewed Nintendo DS game ever, it failed to crack the top ten in sales. In fact, the word on the street is that its sales were less than 90,000 copies. So the seven of you who voted "around 100,000" on the last poll, give yourself a pat on the back and then weep bitter tears of disappointment. 

More bad news is that, despite the number 10 game this month selling around 200,000 copies, MadWorld failed to chart. That means that - while we don't know how many copies it did move - it was definitely less than 200,000. Probably not the kind of sales Sega and Platinum were hoping for, but then again, I was hoping for a game that was less overtly repetitive. 

Wii fans - or at least the ones reading this site - really want M-rated, "traditional" games to take off on Wii and to a lesser extent on DS. This is pretty concrete evidence that it may not happen on Wii and it's definitely not happening on DS. With MadWorld I think it can be debated as to whether or not the game was really good enough to crack the M-rated glass ceiling for Wii, but the sales for Chinatown Wars are just depressng. 

 

Comments [8]

post a comment

  • First
    • Jump To Page:
    • [ 1 ]
  • Last
Existential_11

Bad sells for China Town may be related to the lack luster GTA IV, which also got a ten. This is what happens when review sites hand out high reviews to everyone... games that may deserve to get that high review score lose all of their lime light. If GTA IV got a 4 or 5, and China Town an 8 or 9... I may have wanted China Town.

Existential_11

Bad sells for China Town may be related to the lack luster GTA IV, which also got a ten. This is what happens when review sites hand out high reviews to everyone... games that may deserve to get that high review score lose all of their lime light. If GTA IV got a 4 or 5, and China Town an 8 or 9... I may have wanted China Town.

DJKennethA

Wii's perception might not be helping either, but it just seems like that console keeps being treated more as a toy. It has soo much potential but people aren't buying the M rated stuff. Also makes me wonder if the recession is beginning to affect game sales?

Lynxara

@DJKennethA:

You may be onto something. I'm going to post about this later, but Rockstar issued a statement earlier today on the situation stating that sales of Chinatown Wars experienced a "substantial lift" following the release of the DSi, presumably because people were buying copies along with the new system. So the April NPD may see Chinatown Wars moving more into the sales territory people were expecting.

Xander_RKos

When a dev tells me that a game sold bad, then maybe I'll believe it. Wii and DS games have long legs, like Madworld started off selling slow...like around 20k or so, then 45k, and according to N4G sources, 66k have been moved. It's still selling, it's going to keep selling well into 2010, just like No More Heroes. Chinatown wars is probably going to be the same. Wii games just have long legs, that's how it's been for a while.

Lynxara

@Xander_RKos:

That's not a bad policy to hold. Something to remember, though, is that most devs won't admit a game's sales are bad until they have to explain why a sequel isn't coming out. For instance, Sega never admitted that Shiren the Wanderer sold poorly-- it wasn't clear that it had until XSEED explained why they wouldn't be localizing any Shiren games.

Xander_RKos

Well, I think there are few things here that everyone forgets and that is that none of the games that everyone is holding their breath for to either say hardcore games sell/fail on Nintendo consoles are not worldwide releases. The article posted doesn't say if it's NA only or worldwide, but even still (I'm wondering can give me a new IP game that wasn't released worldwide that did extremely well in it's first five weeks, I haven't found one yet.)

Lynxara

NPD numbers are always for the U.S. market only. Different sources cover Europe, UK, and Japan. Most non-publisher people who claim to have "worldwide numbers" are just adding the different territory numbers together.

As far as new IP goes-- unless Sonic and the Black Knight did really well in Japan, it seems MadWorld's actually managed to beat it for worldwide sales if you tally together the US and UK numbers. (More on that above.)

  • First
    • Jump To Page:
    • [ 1 ]
  • Last

Post a Comment